Joseph Chow ,

Ph.D., PE

Synthetically generated population data can reveal the equity impacts of distributing transportation resources and funding across diverse regions, according to new research from NYU's Tandon School of Engineering that uses New York State as a case study.

Relying on an artificial dataset representing 19.5 million New York residents and over 120,000 modeled origin-destination trips, researchers from NYU Tandon's C2SMARTER, a Tier 1 U.S U.S. Department of Transportation-funded University Transportation Center, determined how best to invest in transportation services when equitable benefits are an objective.

They presented the findings in a paper published in Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment.

"Policymakers often use surveys to allocate transportation resources, but these surveys frequently underrepresent low-income and marginalized communities," said Joseph Chow, Institute Associate Professor of Civil and Urban Engineering, who led the study. "We developed a completely new approach for transportation planning, showing that synthetic data can consistently assess equity impacts across large regions like New York State. Our statewide model parameters are available to any agency to study the multiple effects of new service designs, something previously impossible."

The research team developed what they call an "equity-aware choice-based decision support tool.”

Given a budget level, the proposed tool selects optimal service regions for one or two new mobility services considering four objectives: (1) maximizing total revenue, (2) maximizing total increased consumer surplus, meaning delivering consumers cost savings (3) minimizing consumer surplus disparity, meaning making the benefits fair between different groups and (4) minimizing consumer surplus insufficiency, meaning ensuring baseline benefits even in areas that are less profitable.

The first two objectives focus on making the transportation system more efficient and profitable overall. The last two objectives emphasize making sure the benefits are distributed more equitably among different consumer groups and regions.

Using the tool with New York State synthetic data, researchers focused on two hypothetical mobility services: ride-hailing services that offer shorter travel times but higher trip fares, and on-demand microtransit services that provide longer travel times with lower trip fares. The results showed that:

• Investing mostly in ride-hailing services, focusing on longer trips in metropolitan areas like New York City, maximized revenue.
• Also prioritizing ride-hailing services but covering shorter trips in metropolitan areas maximized consumer surplus.
• Investing mainly in on-demand microtransit service, targeting disadvantaged communities, minimized consumer surplus disparity,
• Splitting the budget between ride-hailing and microtransit services, covering both urban and rural areas, balanced equity and efficiency,

"Microtransit played an outsized role boosting equity, proving more viable in disadvantaged areas. But it needed subsidies to offset lower productivity than ride-hailing,” said Chow, who is also Deputy Director of C2SMARTER. “We hope this study is a step towards creating a way to analyze and allocate transportation resources nationally, to produce equitable outcomes throughout the U.S.

Replica, a transportation data and analytics firm, provided the synthetic data for the study. The dataset combines real mobility, demographic, and built environment information with mathematical models, providing details like travel demand patterns, transportation network characteristics, and mode choices for a given region.

"The work Dr. Chow and the team at NYU Tandon are doing is precisely what we had in mind when making Replica data available," said Robert Regué, Director of Research and Development at Replica. "We believe synthetic data is the key to taking a more data driven approach to creating more equitable, sustainable, and economically resilient cities, while protecting personal privacy. We are always excited to see our data contribute to such thoughtful, impactful research."

Along with Chow, the paper’s authors are NYU Tandon PhD candidate Xiyuan Ren and ChengHe Guan, Assistant Professor of Urban Science and Policy at NYU Shanghai and Global Network Assistant Professor at NYU. The researchers received funding support from C2SMARTER (U.S. Department of Transportation).

Xiyuan Ren, Joseph Y.J. Chow, ChengHe Guan, Mobility service design with equity-aware choice-based decision-support tool: New York case study, Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, Volume 132, 2024, 104255, ISSN 1361-9209,

In the ever-evolving landscape of urban transportation, ride-pooling services have emerged as a promising solution, offering a shared mobility experience that is both cost-effective and environmentally friendly. However, optimizing these services to achieve high ridership while maintaining efficiency has remained a challenge. A new study by NYU Trandon transportation experts proposes a novel algorithm aimed at revolutionizing the way ride-pooling services operate.

Led by Joseph Chow, Institute Associate Professor of Civil and Urban Engineering and Deputy Director of the USDOT Tier 1 University Transportation Center C2SMARTER, the study delves into the intricacies of dynamic routing in ride-pooling services, with a particular focus on the integration of transfers within the system. Transfers, the process of passengers switching between vehicles during their journey, have long been identified as a potential strategy to enhance service availability and fleet efficiency. Yet, the implementation of transfers poses a highly complex routing problem, one that has largely been overlooked in existing literature.

The research team's solution comes in the form of a state-of-the-art dynamic routing algorithm, designed to incorporate synchronized intramodal transfers seamlessly into the ride-pooling experience. Unlike traditional approaches that focus solely on immediate decisions, the proposed algorithm adopts a forward-looking perspective, taking into account the long-term implications of routing choices.

Central to the study is the development of a simulation platform, allowing researchers to implement and test their proposed algorithm in real-world scenarios. Drawing on data from both the Sioux Falls network and the MOIA ride-pooling service in Hamburg, Germany, the team evaluated the performance of their algorithm across various operational settings.

The results of the study are promising, suggesting that the incorporation of transfers into ride-pooling services using the proposed algorithm can lead to significant improvements in fleet utilization and service quality compared to transfers without it. By accounting for the additional opportunity costs of transfer commitments, the proposed algorithm demonstrates a competitive edge over traditional myopic approaches, reducing operating costs per passenger and minimizing the number of rejected ride requests.

While the findings represent a significant advancement in the field of urban transportation, the researchers acknowledge that further validation and refinement are necessary before widespread implementation. Nonetheless, the study marks a pivotal moment in the ongoing quest to optimize ride-pooling services for the cities of tomorrow.

In summary, the contributions of the research can be categorized into three main areas:

1. Development of an innovative online policy and algorithm for operating ride-pooling services with en-route transfers.

2. Identification and integration of a previously overlooked dimension in transfer decisions, leading to a more comprehensive cost function approximation model.

3. Conducting a rigorous simulation-based experiment, utilizing real-world data to compare various operational strategies and validate the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm.

As cities continue to grapple with the challenges of urban mobility, studies like this offer a beacon of hope, paving the way for more efficient, sustainable, and accessible transportation systems.

This research was supported by MOIA.

Namdarpour, F., Liu, B., Kuehnel, N., Zwick, F., & Chow, J. Y. J. (2024). On non-myopic internal transfers in large-scale ride-pooling systems. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 162, 104597. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trc.2024.104597

The e-commerce industry, which has seen remarkable growth over the past decade, experienced an even more accelerated surge in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. This exponential rise in online shopping has triggered a corresponding boom in the parcel delivery sector. However, a glaring gap exists in our understanding of the extensive social and environmental repercussions of this burgeoning industry.

To bridge this knowledge void, researchers at NYU Tandon led by Joseph Chow, Institute Associate Professor of Civil and Urban Engineering and Deputy Director of the C2SMARTER University Transportation Center, have proposed a comprehensive model to scrutinize the multifaceted impacts stemming from the parcel delivery surge. The model's architecture incorporates a parcel generation process, ingeniously converting publicly available data into precise figures detailing parcel volumes and delivery destinations. Additionally, a sophisticated continuous approximation model has been meticulously calibrated to gauge the lengths of parcel service routes.

The veracity of this model was subjected to rigorous examination through a real-world case study, employing a trove of data from the labyrinthine streets of New York City. Impressively, the parcel generation process demonstrated an impressive degree of fidelity to the actual data. Even more striking were the high R2 values, consistently hovering at 98% or greater, characterizing the model's ability to approximate reality. Validation of the model's output was further solidified by comparing it against the tangible UPS truck journeys.

Applying this model to the year 2021, it emerged that residential parcel deliveries in NYC constituted 0.05% of the total daily vehicle-kilometers traveled (VKT), equivalent to a staggering 14.4 metric tons of carbon emissions per day. The COVID-19 pandemic substantially contributed to a surge in parcel deliveries, culminating in an alarming annual greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions figure of 1064.3 metric tons of carbon equivalent (MTCE) within the city's boundaries. To put this in perspective, this is sufficient to power the homes of 532 standard US households for an entire year.

A ray of hope emerges in the form of NYC's existing bike lane infrastructure, which has the capacity to seamlessly replace 17% of parcel deliveries with eco-friendly cargo bikes, thereby precipitating an 11% reduction in VKT. By strategically augmenting this infrastructure with 3 kilometers of bike lanes connecting Amazon facilities, the cargo bike substitution benefit skyrockets from 5% to an impressive 30% reduction in VKT. The prospect becomes even more promising with the construction of an additional 28 kilometers of bike lanes citywide, potentially pushing parcel delivery substitution via cargo bikes from 17% to a remarkable 34%, concurrently saving an extra 2.3 MTCE per day.

Notably, the prioritization of cargo bike deployments holds the potential to disproportionately benefit lower-income neighborhoods, including but not limited to Harlem, Sunset Park, and Bushwick, by substantially curtailing GHG emissions in these communities.

Hai Yang, Hector Landes, Joseph Y.J. Chow, "A large-scale analytical residential parcel delivery model evaluating greenhouse gas emissions, COVID-19 impact, and cargo bikes," International Journal of Transportation Science and Technology, 2023, ISSN 2046-0430.